Best Car Insurance Companies

Best Car Insurance Companies

The Best Car Insurance companies in 2024 provide competitive rates, diverse coverage options, valuable discounts, and user-friendly digital tools tailored to your unique needs. Our research has identified ten top insurers in this space.

We have highlighted key features from each company to assist you in determining which insurer best meets your specific requirements. Since your car insurance needs are unique, it is essential to understand them before comparing different providers to secure the best rates and coverage.

Amica Top Car Insurance Company in 2024

Amica’s outstanding claims service and customer-focused approach make it an excellent choice for drivers looking for a reliable auto insurance company that offers support when it matters most.

If you’re aiming to reduce your auto insurance costs, consider exploring Amica. The company provides a wide range of discounts, such as those for homeowners, multi-vehicle policies, completing a defensive driving course, and enrolling in automatic payments. However, it’s important to remember that the insurer offering the most discounts may not always have the lowest overall.

Auto-Owners insurance company

Auto-Owners Insurance goes beyond car insurance. They offer a variety of insurance options, including home, life, and business coverage, through local agents in 26 states.

If you’re looking for multiple insurance policies, Auto-Owners might be a good choice. They offer bundling discounts for combining policies, saving you money. They also have a strong reputation for customer service and financial stability.

Auto owners are worth considering, especially if you live in a state they serve and have young drivers in your household. They offer student discounts and competitive rates for young drivers, as well as competitive rates for drivers of all ages.

American Family Insurance

American Family Insurance is a major car insurance provider in the United States, known for its good customer service. Founded in 1927, they currently offer insurance in 19 states.

Compared to similar companies, American Family receives significantly fewer complaints from customers about their car insurance. They actively encourage customer feedback through phone, email, and website forms and even showcase positive reviews on their main website.

American Family offers competitive rates for full coverage, even for young drivers or those considered high-risk. While they might not always be the absolute cheapest option, they could be a smart choice for your needs and budget.


Geico is a leading car insurance company in the United States, known for its competitive rates and convenient online and phone options. They offer coverage in all 50 states and Washington, D.C., making them widely accessible.

Geico’s reputation for reliability is reflected in its high ratings. They provide insurance for most driver profiles, even those with past driving mistakes.

Looking for ways to keep your rates low? Geico offers accident forgiveness programs. You can qualify for free forgiveness after five years of accident-free driving with Geico, or you can choose to pay extra for this benefit. Geico is known for its affordability and consistently ranks among the cheapest options in industry analyses.


Progressive stands out as a leading auto insurance provider, holding the number two position in the national market with a significant share of over 14%. Their extensive coverage options and nationwide availability cater to a wide range of drivers, including those with past DUI convictions requiring SR-22 or FR-44 filings. This focus on high-risk drivers is one of the reasons Progressive was recognized as the Best Auto Insurance Company for High-Risk Drivers in 2024.

Progressive goes beyond standard car insurance, offering coverage for various motorized vehicles. They boast a comprehensive range of discounts and coverage options, including rideshare insurance and protection for pets injured in car accidents.

Read Also: Car Insurance Coverage For Natural Disasters

State Farm Best Car Insurance Company in 2024

In a 2023 J.D. Power study on car insurance shopping experiences, they were ranked number one out of eight major insurers.  While their claims satisfaction ranking wasn’t the highest nationally, they did receive the top spot for overall customer satisfaction in the Southwest region.

State Farm’s widespread presence and strong reputation make it a strong choice for car insurance in most states. As the biggest national car insurer based on market share, they have a large network of local agents. This network reflects their commitment to putting customers first and offering a variety of insurance options, both personal and commercial.


USAA stands out as a leading auto insurance provider specifically for military members, veterans, and their families. They offer competitive insurance rates and a variety of financial products like banking and investments for eligible customers.

USAA is known for its exceptional customer satisfaction and offers a discount for storing your car on a military base while deployed. Despite being exclusive to military members, USAA consistently ranks high in J.D. Power’s customer satisfaction and claims satisfaction studies. Additionally, USAA boasts strong financial ratings from Moody’s, AM Best, and S&P, indicating their financial stability.

In short, USAA excels in providing military-focused benefits, including a significant discount (up to 60%) for storing vehicles during deployment.

Liberty Mutual

Liberty Mutual can be a good choice if you’d like the ease of managing your car insurance and other insurance policies, like home insurance, with a single company. Bundling your policies can be both convenient and cost-effective. Liberty Mutual states that customers who switch and bundle their home and auto insurance can save up to $950 per year.

It’s important to note that Liberty Mutual doesn’t advertise its average car insurance rates. To get a personalized quote, you’ll need to contact a Liberty Mutual agent directly.


Travelers have been around for a long time (over 150 years) in the car insurance business. They have a good reputation and are financially stable. Travelers offer many choices for car insurance and work with local agents who can help you find the right plan. Travelers also provide coverage that some other companies don’t, such as protection for newer cars if they are totalled in an accident. If you want to work with an agent and get multiple types of insurance from one company, Travelers might be a good choice for you.

Best Car Insurance Companies Cost

Insurance company Annual full coverage premium
Amica $2,860
Auto-Owners $1,696
Geico $1,984
Progressive $2,055
State Farm $2,624
USAA $2,016
Travelers $1,895
Liberty Mutual Average: $1,483

Should I buy a Minimum Coverage or Full coverage Insurance Policy?

If you’re looking to save money, consider getting minimum coverage car insurance. This is the least amount of insurance you need to legally drive in your state.

However, minimum coverage usually doesn’t cover major accident damage, and you might have to pay out of pocket for any damage you cause after your insurance limit is reached. It also won’t cover damage to your own car.

For better financial protection, choose full coverage insurance. There’s no exact definition of full coverage, but it generally includes your state’s minimum requirements plus comprehensive and collision insurance. Full coverage costs more than minimum coverage, but the extra cost might be worth it for the peace of mind. If you’re financing or leasing your car, you likely already have full coverage insurance.

How to Find the Best Car Insurance Rates

While you can’t control every factor that affects your car insurance cost, there are some steps you can take to get a better rate:

  • Compare Quotes: Different insurance companies calculate premiums in their own way, so prices vary. Taking time to compare quotes from various companies can help you find a lower rate.
  • Shop Early: Start looking for insurance up to a month before your current policy expires. This gives you enough time to get quotes and choose the best option. Remember, most companies require a month’s payment upfront, so plan for that in your budget.
  • Use Discounts: Many insurance companies offer discounts. These can vary, so check with different providers to see what you qualify for.
  • Join a Telematics Program: Some insurers offer discounts if you install a device that tracks your driving habits. Safe driving can lead to lower rates.
  • Maintain a Clean Driving Record: Avoid accidents and traffic tickets, as they can increase your insurance costs.
  • Consider Your Car: If possible, think about switching to a different vehicle that might cost less to insure.
  • Have Realistic Expectations: Not everyone will get the best rates. For example, if you have a DUI on your record, your insurance could be much higher, sometimes up to 92% more.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *